Naschrift

Open Access
Authors
Publication date 2009
Journal Bijdragen en Mededelingen betreffende de Geschiedenis der Nederlanden
Volume | Issue number 124 | 1
Pages (from-to) 82-84
Organisations
  • Faculty of Humanities (FGw) - Amsterdam Institute for Humanities Research (AIHR)
Abstract
The issue that is the subject of discussion here is in fact the main problem: the enormous obedience or the refusal and evasion of clerical precepts by Dutch Catholics. In this postscript the first position in this discussion is maintained. Of course, some interdependency between the laity and the clergy can be seen. But the power of ‘hell and holiness’ was irresistible in instilling obedience. Isolation within the nation was first forced upon the Catholics by a dominant Protestantism; later on it became the result of their own choice, guarded over with much vigour and energy. One final point: the Catholic pillar did not start to crumble in the Interwar period because of all those ‘other Catholics’, otherwise the revolutionary nature of its downfall in the sixties becomes quite unintelligible.
Document type Comment/Letter to the editor
Note Repliek op: P. Lyykx (2009) 'Andere katholieken': een nieuwe visie. - Bijdragen en Mededelingen betreffende de Geschiedenis der Nederlanden, 124(1):75-81.
Language Dutch
Related publication Onheilig moeten: drie studies over aspecten van het katholicisme [Bespreking van: G. Ackermans, M. Monteiro (2007) Mannen Gods: clericale identiteit in verandering; A. van den Oord (2007) Voor het oog van het kerkvolk: Tilburgs volksklasse tussen klerikale normering en geleefde praktijk, 1927-1939; M. Derks (2007) Heilig moeten: radicaal-katholiek en retro-modern in de jaren twintig en dertig]
Published at https://doi.org/10.18352/bmgn-lchr.6897
Downloads
315223.pdf (Final published version)
Permalink to this page
Back