Horror Contradictionis

Open Access
Authors
Publication date 2011
Host editors
  • S.D. Hales
Book title A Companion to Relativism
ISBN
  • 9781405190213
ISBN (electronic)
  • 9781444392494
Series Blackwell Companions to Philosophy
Pages (from-to) 511-525
Publisher Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell
Organisations
  • Interfacultary Research - Institute for Logic, Language and Computation (ILLC)
Abstract

Contradiction between sharp propositions is a major engine of progress in logic, both in reasoning and in related tasks. And yet, in communicative practice, we often try to avoid confl ict, and logic also has several strategies for "defusing" contradictions. This chapter discusses some of these, including changes of arity for predicates, relativization of domains, and retreat to weaker statements about agents'beliefs. I note a few folklore facts about the reach of these methods, and then relate the balance between accepting and defusing contradictions to issues in belief revision and game theory. In doing so, I place "relativism" in a setting of information dynamics: an optimal take on a contradiction depends on its success in facilitating subsequent communication.

Document type Chapter
Language English
Published at https://doi.org/10.1002/9781444392494.ch26
Other links https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/84885832271
Downloads
PP-2009-47.text (Submitted manuscript)
Permalink to this page
Back